|
|
Web News |
BBC news clips, trailers travel to YouTube
The BBC said on Friday that it had started showing promotional trailers for new programs and clips from old hits on Google's YouTube video site in a bid to reach new audiences and boost sales at its commercial arm. News clips will be added in the near future, when...
EU threatens Microsoft with $4 million a day fine
EU COMMISSIONER Neelie Kroes claimed Microsoft is still not coming up with demands for information required and threatened to fine the Vole $4 mill a day unless it coughs up. According to AP, Ms Kroes' department has given Microsoft four weeks to spill the beans on...
Brown set to lure web gaming in from cold
Gordon Brown will announce plans in next month's Budget to encourage the beleaguered online gambling industry to be regulated and licensed by the UK Government. The Treasury has long had its eye...
Retailers suspiciously coy on PlayStation 3 pre-order...
Is it a world-beater waiting to fly off the shelves, or a yawn-inducer that has left gamers with their hands firmly in their pockets? For the UK launch of Sony's PlayStation 3, due on March 23, the answer seems to depend on whether you believe the retailers - who may have....
Website helps locate bursaries
An online map to help prospective students find out which bursaries are being offered by universities and higher education colleges was launched today by the government. The interactive Bursary Aware map will provide links to 219 higher education institutions...
Petition demands Vista price cuts in UK
As businesses and consumers grapple with Microsoft's new operating system, Windows Vista, one question is increasingly being asked. Why is it so much more expensive to buy Vista in the UK than the US?
Virgin customers offered get-out
Virgin Media customers unhappy at losing 24, Lost and The Simpsons will be allowed to cancel their contracts without penalty payments. The cable company announced today that customers who receive just the TV service will be given a once-only opportunity...
E*Trade tests global trading
E*Trade Financial, an online bank and brokerage, has launched a pilot platform that offers U.S. customers electronic access to foreign stocks and currencies in international markets. The platform, which will be widely available in the second quarter, allows E*Trade's...
|
|
|
03.02.07
Managing Emerging Brands, Dealing with PR Fallout
 By
Scott Boyd
It seems that 2007 brings us a “SEOs are teh devil” mantra from a multitude of newly crowned golden children of the web and to be perfectly honest it’s starting to annoy me.
No doubt the likes of Slashdot have already dealt with and got over the impact the SEO industry may or may not have on the operation of their site - having implemented procedures to deal with comment spam, crap submissions and the like, Slashdot is still doing fine. So why are newer community driven big brand sites so anti-SEO?
There has been loads of drama surrounding Digg’s approach to the SEO industry, which has been driven largely by its user base that seems to be largely anti-SEO despite many top Diggers being SEOs themselves. A notable example was Danny’s recent article being buried.
And now, MyBlogLog is getting in on the SEO witch hunt as well, after banning SEO Shoemoney for “publishing other people’s data on the site and urging readers to spoof them”. OK, a fair argument, but ill-timed given that the SEO industry is still fist-shaking after the recent Digg drama.
Regardless of the specifics of each situation, what annoys me is that these large and popular sites are so inadequately handling the nature and reality of the web. Both Digg and MyBlogLog offer a system where websites can promote themselves (submitting an article to Digg; making use of MBL widgets, profiles, etc), yet they seem to be handling the Internet Marketing industry so badly.
We’re not working in a new industry - SEO has been around for years now and it really unbelievably amateurish for such large brands to emerge offering services that are obviously attractive to the marketing industry, yet are unable to manage their online PR with any level of competence.
After burying Danny’s article, the Digg user base now finds itself having lost an insightful and informative article written by one of the industry’s most respected individuals. How does this reflect on Digg?
Eric Marcoullier from MyBlogLog talks about “staying ahead of SEO-types who try to game the system” - no offence Eric, but you (well your company) created the system and it was blatantly obvious to anyone with two brain cells to rub together that this was the inevitable outcome on the back of the system’s success. You created a marketing tool and now are complaining because marketing professionals are using it.
That’s like Google complaining because small businesses who self manage their PPC campaign don’t get as good an ROI or exposure as professionally managed campaigns.
Natural selection anyone?
Try a Better Way Today.
Try WebEx MeetMeNow - Click
Here |
|
Here’s an idea for Digg. Realise that a community based on anonymous voting by a predominately tech geek crowd is an inherently flawed model that will reach a critical mass and then simply fail. Either take your community and refocus it to serve niche markets which would make good use your users’ professional knowledge - or - adapt your system’s model to accommodate mass market use to avoid one social group dominating the results.
Otherwise your site is simply going to become (or stay as) a bitching ground for geeks. We’re all adults here (mostly) - I think it’s time we moved on from the “majority rules and the rest gets binned” philosophy.
How about creating specialist areas for your users so their votes carry more or less weight where their own specialism and past voting history is appropriate?
Here’s an idea for MyBlogLog. Profiles, stats, networking - regardless of how your corporate strategy defines your site, it is in fact a marketing tool for bloggers - within this market, SEO plays a very significant role. To avoid this, ignore it, or even fight against it is an unnatural way to approach the issues you are facing. Embrace the “problems” and reassess your strategy to incorporate new ways to turn them into positives.
Don’t like half naked chicks as avatars? Then implement a review process. PokerStars.com does this for gamer avatars - you need to wait a few days for a review and you can only change your avatar 1 time after this, but there are no offensive images at the tables. And I bet they got way more users than you do!
Don’t like comment spam? It’s not 2002 - there are plenty of ways you can implement self moderation / community moderation features to kill it off.
Don’t like BS communities / profiles that don’t deserve to be there? See above re: community moderation / review process.
The main problem Digg and MBL have is that both sites are based on a LAZY business model. They simply setup free and easy ways for people to contribute the content and have next to no internal review processes in place. And now the sites have reached a critical mass of users that laziness has come back to bite them on the ass - and instead of doing something about it they are pointing fingers.
Change, innovate or be remembered in Friday Foo “what ever happened to” posts.
Comments
About the Author:
Scott Boyd (aka Marketing Guy) is an Edinburgh based online marketing consultant with over 6 years experience in the industry. He is the founder of SEO agency eFlaunt, where he mixes a blend of traditional marketing and SEO.
Scott's musings relating to the marketing and SEO industries can be found on his blog - Fused Nation.
|
